Why is copper the odd one out?
"Why is copper the odd one out?" is a free, interactive Class 12 Chemistry simulation for NEET and JEE, built on the NCERT section "Electrode potentials" in The d- and f-Block Elements. E°(M²⁺/M) built from three bars: atomisation + (IE₁ + IE₂) up, hydration down; the net decides the sign, so Cu ends positive and Mn, Ni, Zn sit below the trend. NEET has asked about this idea 2 times in 10 years of papers. JEE Main asked 61 questions from this chapter across the 42 shifts Lumi has analysed (2017–2026).
From the lesson Electrode potentials in The d- and f-Block Elements. Change the values and watch what happens.
What it shows
NCERT §4.3.5; §4.3.6
E°(M²⁺/M) built from three bars: atomisation + (IE₁ + IE₂) up, hydration down; the net decides the sign, so Cu ends positive and Mn, Ni, Zn sit below the trend.
Controls
3 to try
- Slidermetal Ti–Zn
- ToggleE°(M²⁺/M) / E°(M³⁺/M²⁺) view
- ReadoutsΔaH, IE sum, ΔhydH, net, E°
Try this
Find the only first-row metal whose net energy comes out uphill (positive E°), and the M³⁺/M²⁺ couple with the highest E°.
Common mistake
Mn³⁺ and Cr²⁺ behave alike because both are d⁴.
In NEET
10 years of papers
Asked 2 times in 10 years of NEET.
See the past questions: d- and f-Block Elements, Periodic Properties, The d- and f-Block Elements (chapter)
In JEE Main
42 shifts analysed
61 questions from The d- and f-Block Elements across the 42 JEE Main shifts Lumi has analysed (2017–2026).
The idea behind it
NCERT §4.3.5; §4.3.6
- E°(M²⁺/M) sums up three steps: atomising the metal, removing two electrons (ΔiH₁ + ΔiH₂), and hydrating the M²⁺ ion. First-row values: Ti −1.63, V −1.18, Cr −0.90, Mn −1.18, Fe −0.44, Co −0.28, Ni −0.25, Cu +0.34 and Zn −0.76 V.
- Copper alone has a positive E°(M²⁺/M), so it cannot release H₂ from acids; only oxidising acids (nitric acid and hot concentrated sulphuric acid) attack it, and the acid itself is reduced. Turning Cu(s) into Cu²⁺(aq) costs more energy than the hydration of Cu²⁺ returns.
- The general drift to less negative values across the row follows the rising sum of the first and second ionisation enthalpies.
- Mn, Ni and Zn are more negative than the trend predicts: Mn²⁺ (d⁵) and Zn²⁺ (d¹⁰) have stable configurations, and Ni²⁺ has the most negative hydration enthalpy.
- E°(M³⁺/M²⁺) values: Ti −0.37, V −0.26, Cr −0.41, Mn +1.57, Fe +0.77, Co +1.97 V. Sc³⁺ is very stable (noble gas core), so Sc's value is low.
- Mn's value is high because Mn²⁺ (d⁵) is especially stable, and it is much higher than Cr's or Fe's because the third ionisation enthalpy of Mn (d⁵ → d⁴) is so large; this is why Mn(III) matters little. Fe's value is comparatively low because Fe³⁺ is d⁵. V's is low because V²⁺ has a half-filled t₂g set (Unit 5). Zn would have the highest value, since it would mean breaking into d¹⁰.
- Cr²⁺ and Mn³⁺ are both d⁴, yet Cr²⁺ is a reducing agent (becoming d³, a half-filled t₂g set) while Mn³⁺ is an oxidising agent (becoming d⁵).
Questions
5 answers
- What does the "Why is copper the odd one out?" simulation show?
- E°(M²⁺/M) built from three bars: atomisation + (IE₁ + IE₂) up, hydration down; the net decides the sign, so Cu ends positive and Mn, Ni, Zn sit below the trend.
- What mistake does the "Why is copper the odd one out?" simulation fix?
- A common mistake it clears up: mn³⁺ and Cr²⁺ behave alike because both are d⁴.
- Has NEET asked about this idea?
- Yes. NEET has asked about this idea 2 times in 10 years of papers.
- Does JEE Main ask questions from The d- and f-Block Elements?
- Yes. JEE Main asked 61 questions from this chapter across the 42 shifts Lumi has analysed (2017–2026).
- Is this simulation free?
- Yes. It is free and runs in the browser on a phone or a laptop. It belongs to the lesson "Electrode potentials" in The d- and f-Block Elements (Class 12 Chemistry).
Embed this simulation
Free, with a link back
Teaching this idea? Put the simulation on your own page or LMS with this code.